COMMENTS FROM THE PHOTO JUDGES

The 2026 photo judging panel consisting of Berkley White, Chuck Davis, Becca Boring, Scott Campbell, and Sterling Zumbrunn, evaluated this year’s submissions. As in previous years, one simple question guided every decision: “Would I put this image on my wall?”

This year’s competition produced an incredibly diverse group of winning images, with no single photographer sweeping all categories and no dominant subject, like jellyfish or tuna crabs of previous years. Instead, photographers found success by embracing Monterey’s iconic underwater scenery. Shallow-water kelp forests, sea lions, using divers as models and familiar marine life proved that compelling images don’t require rare subjects; thoughtful composition, timing, and creativity made all the difference.

One technique that stood out was the successful use of motion blur and slow shutter speeds. The strongest images balanced motion with recognizable subjects, creating photographs that felt both artistic and intentional without becoming overly abstract. Images that included a defined background and multiple layers also performed well, adding depth and visual interest that made the photo more engaging.

The judges also noted that while many entries featured technically challenging or rare subjects, technical difficulty alone wasn’t enough. Images that created an emotional connection and left a lasting impression consistently rose to the top under the “Would I put this on my wall?” philosophy.

From a technical standpoint, the judges saw many beautifully composed and well-lit photographs that narrowly missed placing because critical focus fell just short of the eyes or another key feature. They also observed that several images entered in the Traditional categories may have performed better in Unrestricted, where additional cleanup of backscatter, hotspots, or other distractions could have elevated an already strong photograph.

Overall, the judges were extremely impressed by the quality, creativity, and diversity of this year’s submissions and are excited to see how photographers continue to raise the bar at the 2027 Monterey Shootout.